Spring Shoes: Cute & Affordable!

I recently visited Aldo's sister line, Spring Shoes' website and fell in love.  They have a similar aesthetic to Aldo but more affordable.  Though I already thought that Aldo was reasonably priced, Spring Shoes just raised the bar even more!  I have about 5 shoes in my shopping bag--how will I choose??  The most expensive shoe that I've seen was $59.99 and some clearance shoes are as low as $6.98!!  Right now you can get free shipping on all orders, and there are select styles that are an extra 30% off.  Get your shoes before they run out, it's too good of a deal to pass up.

Here are two pieces I'm eyeing:

New: $59.99

On sale: $34.98

Which do you like better? I need opinions stat!